Before you leave...
Take 10% off your first order
10% off
Enter the code below at checkout to get 10% off your first order
Customer Service 844-415-2946
Currency
Free shipping over $100.
Free standard shipping on orders over $100
🕵️♀️ Blind Date with a Book — Murder Mystery: Who Done It Edition
Step into the role of detective with this immersive, interactive Blind Date with a Book experience.
Part mystery novel.
Part case file.
Part cozy night of sleuthing.
This edition transforms your reading time into a solve‑as‑you‑go investigation, complete with clues, suspects, evidence, and a sealed final reveal. Perfect for mystery lovers, thriller fans, and anyone who enjoys a good twist.
🔍 What’s Inside Your Case File
Each Murder Mystery Edition includes handcrafted, boutique‑style elements designed to pull you into the story world:
Mystery Book (Wrapped & Sealed) — hand‑selected thriller or cozy mystery, wrapped in kraft paper with a wax‑sealed “CONFIDENTIAL” band
Case File Envelope — a detective‑style dossier filled with information about the case
Crime Scene Report — typewriter‑style notes, incident details, and first‑look clues
Suspect Cards — motives, alibis, and silhouettes of potential culprits
Evidence Bag — a mini kraft envelope containing items like a torn note, coded message, map fragment, or fingerprint card
Red Herring Card — a misleading clue to keep things interesting
Final Reveal Envelope — sealed with wax; open only after finishing the book to discover the truth
Detective Badge Sticker — your reward for cracking the case
Every detail is designed to feel vintage, mysterious, and immersive — like opening a secret file pulled from a detective’s desk drawer.
Bonus extras
🕯️ Aesthetic & Experience
This edition blends:
Dark academia
Vintage detective noir
Cozy mystery cottagecore
Boutique kraft‑paper charm
Expect wax seals, twine, aged‑paper textures, gold accents, and typewriter fonts
🎁 Perfect For
Mystery lovers
Thriller fans
Book club gifts
Date nights
Birthday surprises
Unique gifts for readers
Anyone who loves puzzles, clues, and immersive storytelling
This is more than a book — it’s an experience.
💛 Upgrade Options
Make your case file even more gift‑ready with optional add‑ons:
Detective's Bundle - Basic Case File + mug + tote
Deluxe Mystery Experience - All above + candle + personalized wax seal kit
Year of Mysteries - 12 book experience - one box per month shipped to you (each box different)
📦 Hand‑Wrapped with Care
Every box is assembled in our Kentucky studio with premium materials, boutique packaging, and a whole lot of love. No two cases are ever the same.
🚚 Shipping & Processing
Every Murder Mystery Edition is handcrafted in our Kentucky studio and packaged with boutique‑level care. Because each case file includes custom‑made elements, your order follows a careful timeline to ensure quality.
Processing Time
3–4 business days to hand‑wrap your book, assemble your case file, and seal your evidence envelope
Shipping Time
5–8 business days via USPS (standard)
Tracking is always included
Your package arrives gift‑ready with no pricing inside
Free Shipping
Enjoy FREE U.S. shipping on orders $35+
Automatically applied at checkout — perfect for adding a mug or tote upgrade
Packaging
Your Murder Mystery Edition ships in:
A sturdy kraft mailer
Protective padding
A sealed inner case file to keep all clues intact
We take great care to ensure your wax seals, envelopes, and evidence pieces arrive in perfect condition.
Gifting
Sending directly to someone?
We can include a handwritten gift note — just add it at checkout.
Zestily reserves the right to accept or decline your order for any reason. We also reserve the right to alter the price of all items we carry at any time, as stated by our policy. Prices are subject to change without notice.
Zestily ships via the US Postal Service, FedEx, DHL, and UPS. Exact methods will vary based on the availability of these services and what is offered at your location. Shipping charges are calculated on the weight of the items within your order, the shipping method you choose, and your location.
Most orders will be shipped within 72 business hours, if, the items are available, and you are unable to make changes to an order once it has been packaged. Orders cannot be canceled once they have been shipped. You may,are however refuse the package, and upon its return receipt, we will credit you for the merchandise. Shipping fees and any return shipping costs will still apply and the responsibility of the buyer.
An email will be sent to the customer with tracking info. Customers may also log into their accounts for tracking information.
Please take a few minutes to check your order. Make sure to check for smaller items in the corners of your box or inside of larger items. If there is any damage or missing items please let us know right away by contacting us.
Please include your name, address, order number, and a picture of the item (if needed). Do you want a replacement, store credit, or a refund?
All returns should have "Returns" written clearly on the outside of the box. Inside the box, include the order number that you are referring to so that we can properly credit your account.
Zestily accepts returned items that are in resalable condition and purchased less than 30 days ago. Refused orders that are returned will be charged return shipping plus a $2.00 fee. Filing of damage or missing package claims with the shipping provider will be the responsibility of Zestily.